Patrick Bracher (ZA)

Subscribe to all posts by Patrick Bracher (ZA)

US court refuses ‘collapse’ cover for decayed building

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 24, 2018 Posted in Insurance

A Federal Appeals Court in the US has refused to grant cover for alleged ‘collapse’ of a building which was insured under a property policy. The building in question had some decayed framing but the framing as a whole was sufficient to support the weight and loads imposed. The court held that the word ‘collapse’ … Continue reading

Proof of online questions in insurance application

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 23, 2018 Posted in Insurance

Insurers could not reject liability on the basis that the insured had deliberately or recklessly misrepresented his address when applying for insurance because there was no clear evidence about the precise wording of the questions which appeared on the computer screen at the time the online application was made. Computer websites allowed the consumer to … Continue reading

Accidental damage occurs by chance and is not deliberate or inevitable

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 23, 2018 Posted in Insurance

The UK high court refused to order insurers to indemnify Leeds Beckett University for the loss of a building which cracked and was subsequently demolished in 2011 because the damage was not accidental. The below-ground blockwork had turned into mush as a result of flowing ground water which the evidence revealed was there at the … Continue reading

Insurance – Is a stationary tractor spraying herbicide being used?

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 17, 2018 Posted in Insurance

This insurance dispute went all the way to the Court of Justice of the European Union which found that the phrase ‘use of vehicles’ in EU law covered any use of a vehicle as a means of transport. The fact that a vehicle is stationary when the accident occurs does not itself preclude the use … Continue reading

No absolute duty to clear natural vegetation to prevent fire spreading

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 17, 2018 Posted in General

A reasonable landowner is not obliged to ensure that in all circumstances any fire on its property will not spread beyond its boundaries. The landowner is obliged to take steps that are reasonable in the circumstances to guard against such an event occurring. If the landowner takes those steps and a fire spreads nevertheless, the … Continue reading

Director’s personal liability (UK)

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 10, 2018 Posted in General

In a UK case the court made some pertinent remarks about the personal liability of a director: A director is not liable for the wrongdoing of her/his company merely by reason of being a director. The director is liable for wrongs personally carried out by her/him. A director is also liable where she or he … Continue reading

Disintegrating foundations caused by flowing water is gradual deterioration

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 10, 2018 Posted in Insurance

A policy exclusion for damage caused by ‘gradual deterioration’ was held to exclude cover where a building had to be demolished by reason of foundations which disintegrated from flowing water. The building was built across a line of an old watercourse with seven natural springs in the vicinity and there was no proper drainage design. … Continue reading

Deafness from acoustic shock caused by a Wagner opera

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 4, 2018 Posted in General

The claimant, a professional viola player at the Royal Opera House, was found to have suffered acoustic shock whilst sitting in front of the brass section of the orchestra during a rehearsal of Wagner’s Ring Cycle. It was found he was exposed to noise levels which created a risk to and resulting injury of his … Continue reading

Armed robbery is vis major

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 3, 2018 Posted in General

Two consignments of cigarettes which were imported into South Africa from Zimbabwe were stolen in August 2009 by unknown armed robbers during a robbery from a customs and excise warehouse. The owners of the consignment claimed a rebate of customs duty under the Customs and Excise Act which allows a rebate in circumstances of vis … Continue reading

Arbitration clause not void for vagueness (UK)

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 3, 2018 Posted in General

The UK Chancery Division held that an arbitration clause, which could be invoked over a dispute whether there had been ‘any major physical or financial change in circumstances affecting the operation’ of Tata Steel which imported goods through a Welsh port, was not void for uncertainty. The court quoted a nice passage from a previous … Continue reading

Strategically blocking an insolvency reorganisation plan is not bad faith (US)

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 2, 2018 Posted in General

Where a creditor blocked a bankruptcy plan by buying available claims to get sufficient votes to do so, it was held that this was not a bad faith purchase. A finding of bad faith requires evidence of an ulterior motive. If a creditor seeks to protect its claim to the fullest extent by a strategic … Continue reading

When the costs exceed the claim (UK)

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 2, 2018 Posted in General

Two UK judges have expressed their dismay over a matter that went to court for three plaintiffs with modest claims in the lower hundreds of pounds where the parties ended up spending GBP2 million on costs. The claim was against an airline for air tickets for cancelled flights. The court observed that from an early … Continue reading

No right to claim for negligent referral (US)

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on July 2, 2018 Posted in General

An appeal court in New Jersey found that there is no law in terms of which a law firm can be held liable for a “negligent referral” for referring a former personal injury client to another lawyer who mishandled the claim. The plaintiff alleged that the referral lawyer who acted in the personal injury matter … Continue reading

Alleged costs to avert business interruption loss rejected (US)

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on June 26, 2018 Posted in Insurance

In July 2012 a fire damaged equipment vital to the production of a steel pipe manufacturing plant in Arkansas. The fire was a covered peril and loss of business income and extra expenses were also covered. The court rejected the insured’s claim for an additional $14 million in mitigation costs incurred allegedly as ‘necessary expenses’ in … Continue reading

Recoverable car hire charges while vehicle repaired (UK)

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on June 26, 2018 Posted in Insurance

When a car is hired whilst a vehicle damaged in an accident is being repaired the claimant is only entitled to the lowest reasonable basic hire rate of a reputable local car hire company. The cost of the collision damage waiver is also allowed. The plaintiff’s Jaguar XJ Supersport V8 was damaged in an accident … Continue reading

Action over stolen trade secrets does not fall under defamation cover (US)

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on June 20, 2018 Posted in Insurance

A US company was sued for misappropriating trade secrets relating to a medical device and poaching a number of employees. The company was insured in terms of an advertising and personal injury section of its commercial general liability policy, and it attempted to allege that there was a claim for implicit defamation obliging the insurers … Continue reading

Scope of arbitration clause (UK)

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on June 20, 2018 Posted in General

The UK Chancery Division held that an arbitration clause relating to any dispute regarding a contractual undertaking to renegotiate port licensing conditions in the event of ‘any major physical or financial change in circumstances affecting the operation’ of the importer’s works, was broad enough to cover a dispute about the fees for the use of … Continue reading

All-Risks policy does not cover non-existent cargo

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on June 19, 2018 Posted in Insurance

The English High Court held that an all-risks marine cargo and storage insurance policy did not cover a loss of copper ingots which were never shipped to the claimant who had in good faith paid for and taken up fraudulent bills of lading. The claimant bought 7 000mt of copper ingots for shipment to China. The … Continue reading

Asbestos exclusion upheld in US

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on June 19, 2018 Posted in Insurance

An exclusion for claims ‘arising out of asbestos’ was upheld by the US Third Circuit because it is unambiguous and therefore enforceable. The Appeal Court overturned a $36 million judgment against the insurer, which is only part of the policyholder’s liability for $120 million worth of asbestos-related claims. The court did not accept the argument that the … Continue reading

Administrative action can be reviewed from when it adversely affects a person’s rights

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on June 12, 2018 Posted in General

The Supreme Court of Appeal decided that a decision by the National Energy Regulator of South Africa to determine gas prices was not reviewable at the stage when NERSA decided on a methodology to determine the prices, but was reviewable when NERSA subsequently determined the prices imposed on customers. In February 2012, NERSA concluded that … Continue reading

European Commission’s approach to artificial intelligence (AI)

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on June 11, 2018 Posted in General

The European Commission has labelled AI as one of the most strategic technologies of the 21st Century (so far of course) and has proposed a three-pronged approach to EU members which is worth considering: Investment in AI research and innovation must be increased. The EU (public and private sectors) is boosting investment by at least … Continue reading

Is continuing to use ship’s engine after alarm accidental loss? (Aus)

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on June 11, 2018 Posted in Insurance

The insured pleasure craft was fitted with a diagnostic system and a critical alarm for low oil pressure or high coolant temperature. When the alarm went off the engines automatically went into limp mode and the engine-operating manual required the engine to be switched off. The insured did not read the manual nor switch off … Continue reading

Cancellation of contract not justified where most of the price already paid and restitution unlikely

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on June 6, 2018 Posted in General

The court refused to uphold cancellation of an agreement of sale for a members’ interest in a close corporation because only a total of R160 000 out of a purchase price of R4 million (96%) was outstanding and three of the appellants had been paid in full. In addition, restitution of the amount already paid was doubtful … Continue reading

Failure to object to short payment may be a waiver and result in prescription

By Patrick Bracher (ZA) on June 4, 2018 Posted in General

An intention to waive must be inferred reasonably; no-one can be presumed to have waived rights without clear proof. The test for such intention is objective. Silence and inaction will do when a positive duty to act or speak arises. A security company rendered security services to a municipality for six years. During the second … Continue reading